Supervision of all offenders in England and Wales is to be taken over by the federal government after severe failings with the part-privatisation of the system.
Contracts with neighborhood rehabilitation firms, which monitor low and medium threat offenders, won’t be renewed.
The Nationwide Probation Service – which manages these posing the very best risk – will take over in December 2020.
It reverses adjustments made 5 years in the past by then Justice Secretary Chris Grayling to drive down re-offending.
Nevertheless, in March the Nationwide Audit Workplace mentioned issues with the brand new system had value taxpayers nearly £500m and that the numbers returning to jail for breaching their licence situations had “skyrocketed”.
And chief probation inspector Dame Glenys Stacey mentioned the mannequin of part-privatisation was “irredeemably flawed” and folks can be safer underneath a system delivered by the general public sector.
She mentioned she was “delighted” about Justice Secretary David Gauke’s choice.
- Probation companies ‘systematically flawed’, says chief inspector
- Rise in deaths of offenders on probation
Beneath the brand new system being introduced by Mr Gauke launched prisoners and people serving neighborhood sentences might be monitored by workers from the Nationwide Probation Service primarily based in eleven new areas.
Every space could have a devoted non-public or voluntary sector associate, liable for unpaid work schemes, drug misuse programmes and coaching programs.
Fee by outcomes – a key ingredient of Mr Grayling’s mannequin – won’t be used.
Nail within the coffin for flagship reforms
The choice to renationalise offender supervision might be seen as an admission by the federal government that Chris Grayling’s flagship reforms have failed.
He went forward in 2014 regardless of quite a few warnings in regards to the appreciable dangers of splitting probation companies between completely different suppliers and introducing a way of payment-by-results.
Probation unions and prison justice consultants urged him to no less than pilot the brand new method, so issues may very well be recognized and rectified. However Mr Grayling went for fast, wholesale change.
He wished the contracts with the non-public firms firmly in place earlier than the 2015 basic election so the system could not be undone if there was a change of presidency.
Nevertheless, inspection after inspection signalled severe issues, with the nail within the coffin being Dame Glenys Stacey’s report in March.
Mr Gauke mentioned non-public companies and voluntary teams would nonetheless have a task to play to ship a “stronger probation system” which reduces repeat offending.
“I desire a smarter justice system that reduces repeat crime by offering strong neighborhood alternate options to ineffective brief jail sentences – supporting offenders to show away from crime for good,” he mentioned.
The MoJ mentioned the reforms introduced on Thursday have been designed to construct on the “profitable components” of the prevailing system, which led to 40,000 extra offenders being supervised yearly.
Probation union Napo welcomed the brand new method however mentioned it will proceed to oppose the involvement of personal companies in rehabilitation programmes.
And shadow justice secretary Richard Burgon mentioned the Conservatives had been “pressured to face actuality” that their probation mannequin was “damaged”.
However talking on behalf of 4 firms which are liable for 17 of 21 neighborhood rehabilitation firms in England and Wales, Janine McDowell, of Sodexo Justice Companies within the UK & Eire, mentioned she was dissatisfied by the choice.
“In addition to rising value and threat, this extra fragmented system will trigger confusion as offenders are handed between numerous organisations for various components of their sentence,” she mentioned.
Are you an ex-offender? What’s your response to this growth? You may get in contact by emailing
It’s also possible to contact us within the following methods:
- Tweet: @BBC_HaveYourSay
- WhatsApp: +44 7555 173285
- Textual content an SMS or MMS to 61124 (UK) or +44 7624 800 100 (worldwide)
- Please learn our phrases & situations